Once ERM is running, why review policy, process and technology together?
The Taiwan Stock Exchange's Risk Management Best Practice Principles for listed companies assign roles to the board, the risk management committee, the risk management unit and each business unit, and Article 22 calls for a risk appetite proposed to and approved by the committee. Writing that into policy is the easy part. The hard part is keeping three layers connected: the appetite statement (policy) caps exposure to any single supplier; do requisitioning and tendering (process) actually check it; does the ERP (technology) calculate the KRI every month and escalate when the threshold is breached?
COSO's 2017 framework, Enterprise Risk Management: Integrating with Strategy and Performance, makes "Review and Revision" one of its five components, with Principle 16, Reviews Risk and Performance. Continuous improvement means regularly confirming that policy, process and data still point to the same thing.
Winners Consulting's value is one team looking at all three layers together: mapping your framework article by article against the Principles, checking that processes are embedded in your existing budgeting and internal control cycles, and verifying KRI data sources and thresholds. We have supported the Taiwan Stock Exchange and the Joint Credit Information Center in integrating internal control systems with multiple management systems. For how KRIs and control effectiveness are implemented, see ERM technical integration.
How does Ahura bring security, continuity and ERM risk records into one evidence chain?
Article 18 of the Principles asks each company to define its own risk categories. Risk assessments from information security, business continuity, AI and other management systems all need to land on one enterprise risk map. Continuous cross-standard integration depends on each risk record being registered once and then reused by every framework and by board reporting.
The Ahura enterprise risk management platform is currently at proof-of-concept (POC) stage. What the POC already provides: 100% on-premises deployment, so board-level risk data never goes to the cloud or leaves your environment; an end-to-end evidence chain in which every approval step, from policy and appetite approval to breach handling, is recorded and which is compatible with EU eIDAS certificates; a distributed group architecture that lets head office set one appetite while each site stays locally compliant; EU multilingual interfaces; and modular extension for EU regulations and international standards.
Cross-standard comparison, gap analysis on uploaded documents, regulatory version timelines and regulatory change tracking are in development and will be released as the POC progresses, and there is no ERM-specific module today. The goal, once they ship, is that risks from every management system map automatically to one taxonomy.
If Winners Consulting audits your risk management framework, how do we agree the roadmap with your committee?
Start by separating two kinds of audit. A Taiwan public company keeps an internal audit unit under the Regulations Governing Establishment of Internal Control Systems by Public Companies, and that unit's core remit is the internal control system. Internal audits of the risk management framework and of management systems such as ISO 27001 or ISO 22301 are a different exercise, run against each standard, and they do not have to be carried out by the internal control audit unit. That is the work we take on through internal audit outsourcing. And when an internal control audit reaches specialist ground such as information security, personal data or business continuity, the audit unit can bring us in as outside experts to perform the audit in that domain.
Article 16 of the same Regulations requires internal auditors to act with independence, objectivity and impartiality, and ISO 19011 lists independence among its auditing principles. Our principle: the consultant who designed your risk policy and processes never audits that design.
Findings are framed around the committee's duty under Article 14 of the Principles to review implementation and recommend improvements, and become a roadmap the committee can approve: which KRIs need new data sources, which appetite limits need recalibration, which treatment plans must be driven to closure. This is neither a statutory financial audit nor certification.
How do supplier and contract manufacturer audits feed back into your ERM risk portfolio?
A single critical supplier can sit in operational, information and compliance risk under Article 18 of the Principles at the same time, and Article 7 of the internal control Regulations lists supplier management and contract manufacturer management within the purchasing and payment cycle. COSO Principle 14, Develops Portfolio View, calls for aggregation, so supplier risk cannot be managed piecemeal department by department.
A supplier audit by Winners Consulting is a second-party audit: we test suppliers against your policy, risk appetite and contracts, and the results flow back into your risk register and KRIs. This is third-party risk management and supply chain assurance, not third-party certification, and no certificate is issued.
| Supplier type | Audit focus (corresponding requirement) | Evidence retained |
|---|---|---|
| Critical and single-source materials suppliers | Principles Art. 18 operational risk; COSO Principle 14 | Supplier concentration KRI, second-source plan |
| Contract manufacturers | Internal control Regulations Art. 7: contract manufacturer management | Contract manufacturing audit records, quality and delivery exception handling |
| IT and cloud service providers | Principles Art. 18 information risk | Supplier security assessment, incident notification records |
| Agents and distributors | Principles Art. 18 compliance and integrity risk | Integrity commitments, due diligence records |
| Logistics and other critical services | Principles Art. 18 other emerging risks (e.g. climate change) | Disruption scenarios and alternatives |
Results land on the same risk portfolio map, so the board sees the full picture of supplier risk.
Official sources
- TWSE regulation database — Risk Management Best-Practice Principles for TWSE/TPEx Listed Companies (Articles 14, 18 and 22) (in Chinese)
- FSC regulations database — Regulations Governing Establishment of Internal Control Systems by Public Companies (Articles 7, 11 and 16; amended 22 April 2024) (in Chinese)
- COSO — Enterprise Risk Management: Integrating with Strategy and Performance, Executive Summary (2017)
- ISO 19011:2026 — Guidelines for auditing management systems (Edition 4, 2026-05; replaces the withdrawn 2018 edition) — ISO
- ISO/TC 176 ISO 9001 Auditing Practices Group — Guidance on internal audits (objectivity and impartiality of the internal audit process; ISO 9004:2018 clause 10.5)
- ISO/TC 176 ISO 9001 Auditing Practices Group — Guidance on ISO 19011 (first-, second- and third-party auditing of management systems)
